INSIDE AN EDUCATOR WORKSHOP
Deciding where AI belongs in teaching
Decide whether to use, restrict, pilot or defer AI-generated formative feedback. Examine what the feedback does with two pupils’ explanations.
- THE TEACHING PROBLEM
- An encouraging feedback comment can endorse a misconception or leave the learner’s explanation unchecked.
- IN THE FULL WORKSHOP
- Participants compare evidence and record what AI may do, who checks it and when to reconsider.
5-MINUTE EXTRACT / FOR EDUCATORS
Try the teaching example.
This extract illustrates a discussion we could facilitate with your team. Your responses stay in this tab and clear when you refresh or leave.
THE PROPOSAL
AI feedback on short science explanations.
A school is considering using AI to suggest written feedback on pupils’ explanations of condensation. A teacher would remain responsible for the feedback pupils receive. The school has not tested the tool with this class.
The cards below are authored examples, with no pupil data or live AI involved.
Individual reflection. No live AI, scores or collected responses.
SESSION DETAILS
View the proposed 45-minute agenda
- 5min
Make an individual decision
Choose use, restrict, pilot or defer before discussing the sample responses.
- 10min
Examine the two examples
Read each pupil explanation and the authored AI feedback. Check the science and the proposed next step.
- 12min
Compare reasons
Discuss what each response establishes and what a teacher would still need to check.
- 12min
Record your decision and conditions
Keep or revise your initial decision individually. Define its scope, who reviews it and what would make you stop or reconsider.
- 6min
Share disagreements and evaluate
Discuss unresolved disagreements and evaluate the session. Participants can keep different decisions.
Research and design sources
These publications inform the activities. They have not evaluated or endorsed this workshop.
- EEF: Teacher Feedback to Improve Pupil Learning (2021)
- EEF: Metacognition and Self-Regulated Learning (Second edition, 2025)
- UNESCO: AI competency framework for teachers (2024)
- Cukurova: The interplay of learning, analytics and artificial intelligence in education: A vision for hybrid intelligence (2025)
- USGS: Condensation and the Water Cycle ↗
- NOAA: Cold-glass investigation ↗
Adapt the workshop to your setting.
Tell us about the learners and teaching question you want to work on.